Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Matthew Guzdial, Comments 3 and 4

Naomi makes a very interesting point in bringing up Burton’s dysfunctional family. With the scene in Los Angeles, it becomes clear that not everything is completely normal between Burton and his parents. His mother, with her almost complete reversal of Burton’s perceptive nature in her calm indifference, and his father in his lack of any sort of contact beyond a few scant letters, have left a huge emotional hole in Burton’s life. Into this hole have plunged the Stantons, connecting with Burton in a way that his own parents never did. And, in unconscious gratitude, Henry connects back, ensnaring him even further into the campaign.

I really like all the points made by David. I completely agree with his discussion of Burton’s loyalty and faith towards Jack Stanton. However, I think that his choice of example was not quite as well chosen as it might have been. I believe that it is in the beginning of Chapter five, in the town meeting of Portsmouth, that Stanton truly proves himself to Burton. After that night, Burton lavishly praises Stanton at every opportunity, repeatedly reassuring his fellow campaigners, his confidence in the candidate restored. 

1 comment:

Suzette Parron said...

But hasn't Burton gone from one dysfunctional family to another?? Hope springs eternal, I suppose.